Critic Reviews
P.S. I Love You (2007) Rank 1 Reviews
Expert Review Summary
based on (121) reviews
Click on the numbers to the right of the graph to see reviews of that rating
Reviews by Score:
ReelTalk Movie Reviews (Geoff Roberts)
Hilary Swank and Gerard Butler appear unconvincing as lovers -- let alone soul-mates -- in the few scenes they have together here. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at ReelTalk Movie Reviews (Geoff Roberts)
PopMatters (Cynthia Fuchs)
For all his plain-speaking, down-homey affect, Harry Connick, Jr. remains something of a mystery. While it’s easy to appreciate his dedication to New Orleans’ recovery or his uncanny appropriation of Sinatra’s swing, his movie career is curious. Rel ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at PopMatters (Cynthia Fuchs)
ComingSoon.net (Edward Douglas)
Even fans of the romantic comedy genre might have trouble suspending disbelief for this ridiculous bit of fluff that rarely knows whether it wants to be a serious drama about grieving or a light comedy about finding love. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at ComingSoon.net (Edward Douglas)
Salt Lake Tribune (Sean Means)
Alas, we never buy the depth of Holly and Gerry's love because the chemistry between Swank and Butler is nonexistent. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Salt Lake Tribune (Sean Means)
MovieFreak.com (Sara M. Fetters)
Heavy handed and entirely too maudlin, this supposedly empowering feminine journey of self discovery is anything but. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at MovieFreak.com (Sara M. Fetters)
New York Post (Lou Lumenick)
A protracted piece of schmaltz. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at New York Post (Lou Lumenick)
New York Daily News (Jack Mathews)
P.S. Why should we care? ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at New York Daily News (Jack Mathews)
TV Guide's Movie Guide (Maitland McDonagh)
It's tough going relieved only by some lovely Irish scenery. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at TV Guide's Movie Guide (Maitland McDonagh)
Toronto Star (Susan Walker)
It's the sort of movie that no man will ever go to unless dragged by a woman. His sole reward will be the sight of Swank in sexy underwear. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Toronto Star (Susan Walker)
Entertainment Spectrum (Vince Koehler)
Punch line should read P.S. I Love You %u2013 If you can sit through this 2 hour film and not become nauseated. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Entertainment Spectrum (Vince Koehler)
San Francisco Chronicle (David Wiegand)
This is a movie that will leave you stunned and stupefied from beginning to end, if you don't head for the exits first. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at San Francisco Chronicle (David Wiegand)
Creative Loafing (Matt Brunson)
P.S. I Love You runs 126 minutes, and that extra half-hour bloats the material into an ugly mishmash in which the attempts at comedy are excruciating and the drama gets diluted by needless set-pieces. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Creative Loafing (Matt Brunson)
Minneapolis Star Tribune (Colin Covert)
Who should be more insulted by P.S. I Love You : Women, who are portrayed as shrill, materialistic harpies who fall down regularly? Or men, who are shown to be at their most romantically attractive when they're dead? ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Minneapolis Star Tribune (Colin Covert)
Boston Globe
Could there be a more selfless star than Hilary Swank? Having ascended to fame like an angel playing women who die, she's generously decided in "P.S. I Love You" to give someone else a chance. This time it's Gerard Butler - wait a minute, didn't he just ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Boston Globe
Slant Magazine (Nick Schager)
There are many good actresses unsuited for romantic comedies, and Hilary Swank, despite her considerable talents, is one of them. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Slant Magazine (Nick Schager)
Sun Publications (Chicago, IL) (Josh Larsen)
...can't quite nail a consistent tone. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Sun Publications (Chicago, IL) (Josh Larsen)
Boston Globe (Wesley Morris)
P.S. I Love You is blithely inept. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Boston Globe (Wesley Morris)
Chicago Reader (Jonathan Rosenbaum)
B.S. I Love You would be a more accurate title. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Chicago Reader (Jonathan Rosenbaum)
L.A. Weekly (Ella Taylor)
LaGravenese has sliced away the worst of Ahern’s excruciating prose, but that proves a negative virtue. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at L.A. Weekly (Ella Taylor)
Arizona Daily Star (Phil Villarreal)
P.S. I don't like you at all. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Arizona Daily Star (Phil Villarreal)
Charlotte Weekly (Sean O'Connell)
Austin Chronicle (Marc Savlov)
LaGravenese is usually a terrific screenwriter, but this adaptation (with Steve Rogers) of Cecelia Ahern's novel is almost insufferably sufferable. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Austin Chronicle (Marc Savlov)
Los Angeles Times (Carina Chocano)
You could go see P.S. I Love You , or you could hit yourself on the head with a meat mallet. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Los Angeles Times (Carina Chocano)
Film Threat, Hollywood's Indie Voice
Jam! Movies (Kevin Williamson)
A low point in the tear-stained history of sappy, shallow chick drivel. ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Jam! Movies (Kevin Williamson)
Orlando Weekly (John Thomason)
Middlebrow mediocrities like You’ve Got Mail look like canonized masterpieces next to P.S. I Love You, a romantic dramedy that stumbles through its excruciatingly Oscar-padded 126-minute running time with no end in sight. Holly Kennedy (Hilary Swank, ...read the complete P.S. I Love You movie review at Orlando Weekly (John Thomason)
from $11.78
(17 sellers)
User Reviews
User Comments
del.icio.us
Digg
StumbleUpon
Yahoo! My Web
Facebook
Google Bookmarks
ma.gnolia
Newsvine
reddit
Windows Live
