Critic Reviews

One Night at McCool's (2001) Rank 4 Reviews

Expert Review Summary

Movie critics combined give One Night at McCool's (2001) a score of 2.5692 out of 4

based on (144) reviews

Click on the numbers to the right of the graph to see reviews of that rating

Excellent

(5)

Very Good

(101)

Good

(28)

Fair

(9)

Poor

(1)

Reviews by Score:

The Movie Chicks

PUBLICITY POSTER - ©2001 - USA FILMS "It all started one night at McCool's�" That's how Randy (Matt Dillon), Carl (Paul Reiser), and Detective Dehling (John Goodman) each start their story about the night that they fell in love with ...read the complete One Night at McCool's movie review at The Movie Chicks

ViewLondon (Matthew Turner)

Frequently amusing black comedy that plays fast and loose with film noir conventions.Very similar in tone to 1999�s Wild Things (which also starred Matt Dillon), One Night At McCool�s is a black comedy with its tongue firmly in cheek, taking the basic ...read the complete One Night at McCool's movie review at ViewLondon (Matthew Turner)

Monkeyboy Review

Mmmm, I'm sitting here, smoking a fag, and I'm thinking Liv Tyler. I'm thinking Liv Tyler, washing a car and soaping her knockers up. I'm thinking, Liv Tyler wrestling nude with Sarah Michelle Gellar in a vat of sweet, sweet chocolate. Mmmmmmmm. ...read the complete One Night at McCool's movie review at Monkeyboy Review

Boxoffice Magazine

Despite the claim that the film has been "formatted to fit your TV," the underrated comedy "One Night at McCool's" appears to really have been just marginally "open-matted" to a 1.77:1 aspect ratio. So those worrying that this DVD might have been ...read the complete One Night at McCool's movie review at Boxoffice Magazine

Arkansas Democrat-Gazette (Philip Martin)

...a breezy, nasty little film that delivers more than it promises. ...read the complete One Night at McCool's movie review at Arkansas Democrat-Gazette (Philip Martin)